Hit Batter Procedure
One of the toughest calls for an umpire is deciding whether a pitch hit the batter or the bat. However, by following some guidelines, umpires can considerably increase their accuracy in getting the call correct.
1) LISTEN - Usually, a ball hitting the bat will have a sharp sound, whereas a ball hitting a batter will have somewhat of a duller sound.
2) DON’T CALL IT TOO SOON - The best thing to do is to just raise both hands slightly more than head high and announce, “Time” At this point you have not committed yourself to anything. If you are sure the ball hit the batter, point the batter to first base. (Left hand is preferred). If you are not sure the ball hit the batter then:
3) OBSERVE - Watch the IMMEDIATE reaction of the batter. If the batter has been hit, they will usually react (especially facially) immediately without thinking. If the batter does not react, or there is a noticeable delay in the batter’s reaction, it is quite likely the batter was not hit by the ball.
4) INSPECT - Look at the batter’s hand. Ask him/her to show you where the ball hit him. A ball hitting a batter’s hand will usually leave some sort of a mark, whether he is wearing a batter’s glove or not.
5) CONSULT - As a last resort, don’t be afraid to ask your partner(s). Although a considerable distance away, sometimes a base umpire has a perfect angle to see what happened. A base umpire must be 100% sure of what they saw before offering information to the plate umpire.
6) TAKING ONE FOR THE TEAM—Be aware of the game situation. Note the speed of the pitch and what the batter does, if anything, to avoid the pitch. Many times, it is the batter who causes the contact by leaning or turning into the pitch. Sometimes batters will extend an elbow. Don’t be afraid to call a strike, or ball, and award first base, if the batter sticks a knee out and the pitch hits him/her on the knee. A good response to a coach, when appropriate, is to say, “Coach the ball was over the plate when it hit your batter.” Or, “Coach it was your batter who caused the contact with the ball.”
Remember that on a fastball, or wild pitch, the batter may not have time to react. Very few batters are willing to take a fastball in the ribs. Use good judgment here and if you believe it is justified, award the batter first base even if he makes no effort to avoid the pitch.
By following the above steps umpires, more likely than not, you will get the hit batter play right.
Western Region Umpire in Chief